I looked up my rating on and luckily did not find any bad reviews on me.  There were a couple of ratings from 5 years ago when I used to teach high school, but none since I have been teaching middle school.  This is probably an issue for high school teachers, but if middle school students find out about this, they would even more likely use this site inappropriately.  Part of me likes the idea of kids being able to have some input in the process.  We have all seen those really bad teachers who really should not be in the business, but it really should be the administrators who get rid of them and find a healthier way to get student input.  This website opens up some real problems with students who just happened to be angry that day.

Some rights reserved by sizumaru

I have to admit, if I were an administrator I would check this website before I hired anyone.  If I saw many disgruntled students it would indicate to me a risk to hire that teacher and many good reviews could mean a very well liked teacher that might be a great asset to our school.  But we know that the students who are upset are most likely to fill out the review and those that are content might not bother to write anything.  Teachers could also make reviews themselves that make them look good.  This website is a great example of how information on the internet can be abused and just plain wrong.  Of course, I like the idea that some positive reviews written about me will be on the internet for many to find, but there will always be a fear that some student will make a negative post about me that will also be there forever.  Of course, I might do something that needs criticism, but we all make mistakes and we should not have those mistakes follow us publicly for the rest of our lives.  Is there some legal action that teachers can take to protect them from this kind of libel?  It seems to me that the damage done to teachers by this website could be very significant.


This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to

  1. Pingback: Private Footprints | COETAIL Online Cohort 2012-2013

  2. Avatar of sleonardis sleonardis says:

    I think it’s scary to think that admin would check this site. Kids have bad days and they love to rate online. It’s similar to the information that you can get from ISR. You have to take it all with a grain of salt. How would you feel as an admin about a teacher with no reviews?

  3. Avatar of Dan Dan says:

    Hey Seth, I admit, I tried my name to see if there was anything and didn’t
    find any information. This is probably due to the fact that I have never
    taught in the US or in Canada. All my teaching has been abroad. I feel the
    same. Part of me likes the idea of this, but on the other hand I’m not sure
    if I am comfortable with the possibility of everyone seeing the information.
    I’m not sure if elementary students would use this appropriately as well. As
    Jeff mentioned, I wonder if an International rate your teacher is going to
    emerge in the future. If so, you can bet ISS, Search Associates, ECIS, and
    others will sure use it!

  4. Avatar of Rick Monge Rick Monge says:

    The scary part of this is that just like with product reviews, the people who are the most likely to post tend to be the people who are disgruntled or who get bad service. The people who get great service are frequently satisfied and silent.

    Particularly at first, people might be outraged when they see negative posts on a teacher, but will have to get used to what proportion of good vs bad would indicate an effective teacher. I can tell you first hand that some of what I would call the worst teachers I have had and worked with have been popular, while some of the best have a number of students who love them and a number of students who despise them. Figuring out how to interpret that information can be a frightening challenge.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>